April 4, 2024
Good Morning. I am not a women’s basketball fan and thus have not paid much attention to all the adoration for Caitlin Clark. I did not watch the Iowa-LSU game, although my better half did. I spent my time working on my latest jigsaw puzzle. Even when I was on the faculty at the university of Tennessee, I went to very few of the Lady Vols games. I never could get over how many layups were missed in the women’s game. Just like I have always been puzzled how poor the free throw shooting is in the men’s game. I am simply not a basketball fan. Yet I was surprised and disappointed when UT fired the women’s coach, Kellie Harper. I served on UT’s athletic board and remembered her as a guard on three of Pat Summitt’s national championship teams. She became a very good coach and I was delighted when she came back to Knoxville to replace Holly Warlick who had followed Summitt. I thought Harper was doing an excellent job with her only shortcoming was the lack of being able to recruit star caliber players. By the time she came to Knoxville, South Carolina was the dominant SEC team followed by LSU. On the national scene Gene Auriemma’s UConn teams who had eclipsed Summitt’s UT teams were no longer dominating the national scene. UConn was still unbeatable in the Big East but was not even a number one seed in this year’s NCAA tournament. Back at UT, Harper was 108-52 (.675). This season UT went 20-13, 10-6 in the SEC and lost to an undefeated South Carolina team on a last second lucky three point shot by a player who had never before made a three pointer. UT lost in the tournament to a North Carolina State team that made the Final 4. Harper had never gotten past the Sweet 16 and I guess that many have been her downfall. By firing her, Tennessee lost her two five star commits and her replacement will likely do worse.
The women’s game has changed but I don’t think Tennessee should have fired Harper. Her firing is reminiscent of Texas’ firing of current Tennessee men’s coach Rick Barnes. Barnes has always been a good coach. His Texas teams were always good but never great even when they had unbelievable talent such as T J Ford and Kevin Durant. Barnes was 402-180 (.691) in Austin. He went to the Sweet 16 five times, to the Elite 8 three times and to the Final Four once. Ultimately he was fired despite that record. He could never win the big one.
At Tennessee, Barnes is 202-101 (.667). Tennessee has gone to 6 NCAA tournaments under Barnes. But similar to his tenure at Texas, Tennessee has been a disappointment in the tournament. They have been to the Elite 8 only twice and never played in the Final 4. Thus, Harper’s record at Tennessee is similar to that of Barnes. She even has a higher winning percentage. Yet there is virtually no chance that Barnes will face the same fate as Harper. One wonders why. Vol great Kara Lawson (one of my former students) is the head coach at Duke. She is one of those rumored to be the next Tennessee coach. Yet Lawson has only been at Duke since 2020, is 69-33 overall and only 32-23 in the ACC – a conference not as strong as the SEC. Her team this year made it to their first Sweet Sixteen. Lawson is one of my favorite people but her record at Duke is not better than Harper’s. She is building a strong program at Duke and can make that her legacy. She cannot have that at Tennessee where Summitt looms larger than life. At Duke she can become the women’s Mike Krzyzewski. She cannot do that at Tennessee. I hope she stays at Duke.