The Black Sea: More dangerous than Hormuz

The Black Sea: More dangerous than Hormuz

A summary of news reports

All eyes have been on the Strait of Hormuz when in fact the Black Sea is a much deadlier place, points out The Wall Street Journal. https://www.wsj.com/world/this-shipping-lane-is-now-the-worlds-deadliest-it-isnt-hormuz-c3acdcaa

The Financial Times reported in late October that, according to the maritime security firm Ambrey and the International Maritime Organization, attacks on commercial vessels in the Black Sea have reached levels more than six times higher than those recorded in the Persian Gulf.

“This year, there have been over 300 attacks in the Black Sea, according to figures from maritime security company Ambrey. The strikes have killed more than 30 seafarers and left more than 20 others missing, according to the Turkish Shipowners’ Association, MarineTraffic reports and local authorities. That compares with around 130 attacks in the Strait of Hormuz and the wider Middle East, in which 25 seafarers have died.”

Ambrey’s figures show that about 387 ships were struck between July and September, and that Russia was responsible for roughly 90% of the attacks in the 45 days before late October. More than 570 vessels have been struck in the Black Sea so far this year.

This, of course, is a direct consequence of the Russia–Ukraine war. Over the summer, Ukrainian drone attacks forced Russia to halt most of its shipping for several months. In recent weeks, ships sailing to and from Ukraine, Romania, Bulgaria, Turkey and Georgia have generally hugged the coastlines for protection against Russian attacks. Earlier in the war, under international pressure, Russian warships had largely stopped targeting merchant vessels carrying grain and other foodstuffs from Ukraine; that is no longer the case. Countries across Africa and parts of the Middle East depend on Ukraine’s harvests to feed their people.

“The economic consequences reach well beyond the two belligerents. The Black Sea carried most of the grain that the two countries exported in the 2025-26 season, namely 37.5 million tons from Ukraine and 46.3 million tons through Russia’s Black Sea and Azov ports. It also carries about 80% of Kazakhstan’s oil exports, and in the first half of this year Kazakhstan sent about three-quarters of its oil exports to European Union countries. Since late July, almost no merchant ships have called at Ukraine’s main ports, and in September Russia shipped only 0.3 million tons of grain through the Black Sea and Azov, against 4.74 million a year earlier.” https://www.geopoliticalmonitor.com/the-black-sea-drone-war-why-no-navy-can-protect-shipping/

The concern is that the attacks are affecting NATO countries Bulgaria, Romania and Turkey. When Ukraine diverted its exports to its Danube River ports and through Romania’s Sulina Canal, Russia followed the cargo. In recent months, drones struck ships trading with Ukraine inside the exclusive economic zones of Romania and Bulgaria and, in one case, inside Romanian territorial waters. Turkey has called for an immediate ceasefire and for diplomacy and dialogue, while Romania has said that threats to navigation have increased manifold and that the government is strengthening its surveillance, counter-drone and mine-countermeasures capabilities. NATO has decided to send additional maritime patrol aircraft, radar systems, drones and intelligence teams to the Black Sea to uphold the maritime security of its member states.

The world is truly a dangerous place.

One thought on “The Black Sea: More dangerous than Hormuz”

  1. Reading the second link, I didn’t see any notice of the impact on animals or the fishing trade. If a ship is sunk, I imagine oil- in the tanks or for transportation- must go into the water..

    Couldn’t access the first article, but was impressed by the orange evacuation boat in the picture..

    Because The Strait has been discussed as the cause of starvation in Africa, having to do with delayed shipments of fertilizer, I would imagine there’s other food sources affected in the Black Sea. And loss is not limited to shipments of grain or supplies.
    Global markets are great… when they work.

    When visited my Navy brother, who was in San Diego, I wanted to see the Exxon Valdez now in-port. He had no intention of taking me. So I got up one morning in a city I didn’t know, took public transportation then a commuter line that I’d never been on- and headed to port.
    Before I got off the train, I could see what all the fuss was about. The ship was huge. And the wreck was now unimaginable, even tho I had seen it constantly in the news.
    Then I took the line back, along with all the Mexican workers.

    In any case , war is a constant battle of an ‘eye for an eye’ , which will make the world blind ; but also a ‘tooth for a tooth’ , meaning the world will eat at Bernie Sanders’ house- because a toothless world can only eat “ seoup!”.

    Like

Leave a Reply